Natalee Holloway: A Case That Captivated The Nation

John Kept A Trophy

Gabriel records his and John’s trip to Aruba on his cell phone. John has an unnerving smile throughout the video. They travel to John’s aunt’s house because according to John, there is evidence of Natalee’s remains on the property that he kept as a trophy. John begins to dig in the ground by a stone wall, and pulls out a small plastic baggy containing bone fragments that he claims are Natalee’s. John seems strangely happy that they finally uncovered some evidence.

Gabriel becomes overwhelmed with emotion. He later texts Dave a photo of the remains.